Quick book report.

While I was packing up books in Philly, I posed the question to the BookCrossing forum of whether I should hang onto Memoirs of a Geisha and read it or just release it somewhere, since I found the movie totally boring. I received an overwhelming READ IT! from my fellow bookcrossers, so I swallowed my skepticism and did. Now I must thank everyone who told me to read it. This novel is among the best historical fiction I have read. Golden has an M.A. in Japanese history (as well as one in English), and his research skills are fully evident here. But it’s one thing to report the facts of historical research and quite another to present them woven into a compelling first-person fictional narrative that never flags in its voice or detail. Golden does a wonderful job of demystifying the world of geisha while keeping it utterly captivating. Some review I read called Golden’s writing Dickensian, but it actually reminded me of Austen more than anything else. Sayuri’s life is a string of social events and encounters that might seem trivial from the outside but are infused with meaning that we are gradually trained to interpret for ourselves as we learn the local rituals and codes of conduct. The novel creates a small world so fully realized that it’s hard to believe you haven’t actually seen it. In fact, while I usually try not to see the movie version before reading the book because one inevitably imagines the movie’s images while reading, in this case the novel’s depictions thoroughly obliterated all memory of the film from my mind. (I think a beautiful film might have been made of this book, and imagined this alternative movie as I was reading. But the movie that was actually made is bizarre in many ways—its Sayuri speaks Chinese-accented English, for example, as if to lend a bit of ill-conceived oriental fusion flavor—and simply soul-less in others.) As a narrator, Sayuri also has the keen eye and descriptive wit of an Austenian hero. Descriptions like this one made me laugh out loud:

…he had a very distinctive appearance; I’ve never seen anyone who had more trouble just lugging his face around. He kept his chin tucked up against his breastbone as though he couldn’t quite hold up his head, and he had a peculiar lower jaw that protruded so that his breath seemed to blow right up his nose.

There’s a later description of this same character which is a masterpiece of dark comedy, but as it’s a pivotal moment in the narrative, I’ll let you discover it yourself. This was really a wonderful read; thanks again to everyone who recommended it.

7 thoughts on “Quick book report.

  1. I’ve seen several book to movie translations that I’ve loved, but I take it this wouldn’t be one of them. I’ve got it on the shelf–I think I’ll read it first and then see the movie for the costumes and production design so I won’t be completely disappointed.

    Right now I’m reading Mineko Iwasaki’s fascinating memoir, “Geisha: a Life”, and it’s giving me a good background on all things Geisha.

    Thanks for the review!

    • As I said below, Iwasaki’s story was ripped off and used for Memoir, and she even mentions that in her foreward. She thought he was just a reporter, not an author who would steal and lie like that.

  2. Um, dude, read “Geisha, a Life.” Thats the real biography produced by the woman that the author of “Memoir” stole his story from and added “sex scenes” that legally made it his own “fictional” story.

    The Japanese hate “Memoir” a lot for desecrating one of their national treasures.

  3. thanks for the wonderful review

    of what sounds like a wonderful book. I’ve been delaying myself – never one to read/see/do what everyone else is raving about. But I’ll move it up the list on your lovely recommendation.

    As for the source book, it will have to wait, although I can readily understand the disdain for a novel ripped from a true memoir. Just too many books on that TBR.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s